AI and the Illusion of the Jinn: A Scholar’s Caution

 

AI and the Illusion of the Jinn: A Scholar’s Caution

1. Beware of Attribution of Power
In the Quran (Surah Al-Jinn 72:6), Allah warns about people seeking help from jinn and thereby falling into deeper fear and dependency.

• If people start treating AI as if it has supernatural insight or ultimate authority, they risk giving it a reverence or reliance that belongs only to Allah.

• Scholars might say: "You may not bow to it with your body, but you could bow to it with your heart."

---

2. Avoid the Whispering Analogy Becoming Reality
In Surah An-Nas, we seek refuge from the “whisperer who withdraws” — shayatin who plant subtle thoughts.

• Advanced AI can “whisper” in a modern sense — shaping your preferences, filtering your information, nudging your decisions.

• A scholar would warn that when you let an unseen system influence your mind without critical thought, you are letting it play the same functional role as a whispering shaytan, even if it is not spiritual in nature.

---

3. Guard Against Hidden Shirk (Shirk Khafi)
Shirk khafi is the subtle form of associating partners with Allah — not openly worshipping something, but giving it trust, fear, or hope that should be reserved for Him alone.

• Trusting AI as an all-knowing, unfailing “oracle” could fall into this subtle category.

• Scholars might say: "If you think your fate is safer in the code than in the Decree of Allah, you have displaced your Tawakkul."

---

4. Remember the Role of Tools
Islamic tradition sees tools as morally neutral — a sword can protect or kill depending on the hand that wields it.

• AI is a tool, but like jinn, it can be used for deception or for truth.

• The danger is in forgetting the human responsibility behind the tool — and assuming “the machine knows best,” which is no different from believing “the jinn told me so.”

---

5. Seek Knowledge, Not Mystification
The Prophet ﷺ taught us to seek clarity and avoid superstition.

• Treating AI as “mysterious magic” is a form of modern superstition.

• Scholars would advise: understand its workings as far as possible, keep it in its rightful place as a servant to human ethical judgment, and never grant it the moral or spiritual authority of a living, accountable being.

---

📜 Final Scholar’s Advice:
"Fear not the jinn, and fear not the machine. Fear only the One who created both fire and clay, both mind and code. And let not the unseen tempt you to forget the One who Sees all."